From AIGA Insight ~ Topics: diversity, membership
Why Double the Number of AIGA Members?
AIGA has set a goal of doubling its professional membership to 20,000 by the year 2010. Why would an organization that seeks to be the preeminent association for designers—representing the highest standards of design excellence and professionalism—seemingly pursue quantity without discussing quality?
Because we must ensure the profession’s impact and relevance.
AIGA has evolved since its founding in 1914, when it brought together a mere score of graphic artists, then consisting of photographers, illustrators, printers, book designers, publishers and lithographers, as well as fine artists.
Today, AIGA counts 10,000 professional members. Yet, we believe the number of designers who are practicing in the United States alone totals approximately 180,000—two thirds of whom work in corporate settings and one third in design studios.
Despite vast changes in the profession, the central interests of members are startlingly consistent with the original ideals: to stimulate thinking about design; to demonstrate the value of design; and to empower designers across the arc of their career. AIGA’s mission, recently reformulated, goes even further: to advance designing as a professional craft, strategic tool and vital cultural force.
It’s about scale
To meet these goals, we need to create an engaged community, help designers to share information, build understanding for the role of the designer and hence earn respect for that role. The eternal issue is how we can enhance the relevance of design as the society, commerce and popular culture are changing so rapidly around us.
We need scale to accomplish these goals, to develop a cohesive and resonant voice from among AIGA’s membership that articulates a consistent story about designing, design and designers. Through network effects, this voice and story will influence other designers to meet the expectations of professionalism that members have set in AIGA’s statement of professional standards. Many designers who have not yet joined AIGA may not understand how critical it is for them to be part of a profession that develops a common voice.
It’s about relevance
The U.S. Census has just reported that among Americans aged 19 or younger, 42 percent are other than white Caucasian.1 Yet only 10 percent of the design profession is other than white Caucasian. If the profession is to serve a diverse public, then it must, for business reasons as well as moral reasons, grow to include (and encourage) many more designers from diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds.
The global economy is changing into one that will be multi-centered, unlike the U.S.-led world economy of the past. This means that AIGA must also work with international peers in order to represent U.S. designers and the high standards for design that they have set.
The present opportunities are as clear as the challenges we must meet in order to sustain the relevance of design well into the future. We believe that consistent messaging about design is important for the profession, as its influence grows in commerce and society. These consistent messages will be heard when they represent a larger number of designers and when those designers show a commitment to articulating them. The more members we have, the stronger the impact we will have in advancing designing here and abroad.
Many are already invested
AIGA’s target of doubling its members in the next three years is doable and necessary, given the expectations members have created for us. We need the support of more designers to make it a reality.
Fortunately, the standards espoused and advocated by AIGA are recognized as being critical to the growth of the entire design economy (and as necessary to drive the innovation associated with design’s impact on business strategies). We have the support of AIGA’s leadership and the involvement of current members. AIGA also has the respect of our colleagues in other fields of design.
We have the partnership of corporate supporters, who know that AIGA’s role—in increasing understanding of the value that design can create—also builds a stronger design economy, which will benefit all. For instance, the membership campaign launched early this summer is supported generously by Neenah Paper, one of our earliest corporate sponsors and a company that realizes that AIGA’s success adds to its own success. Neenah is invested in the success of AIGA. Similarly other AIGA partners have sought ways to work with us to strengthen AIGA and its membership for the long-term interests of the profession.
It’s your profession; make something of it
To double the professional membership and increase our voice and impact, we will need to bring back members who have allowed their memberships to lapse. We must encourage those who attend our conferences and enter our competitions to join. We must encourage new members from among corporate design departments and from groups who have not previously joined. Obviously, AIGA must continue to increase the value of the services we offer, although the enhancements will tend to be in the areas of advocacy for the profession and communication of the value of design to the public, media and business, The true value of each member’s investment in AIGA is our ability to strengthen the relevance of a designer’s contribution to business, society and culture today and far into the future.
Membership is an investment in the future of your chosen profession. Please join us, become engaged in developing that future, and help us to find new members. As our 100th anniversary approaches, AIGA is gearing up for its second century—yet we are just beginning to take the design profession to the role of leadership and respect it deserves.
Notes:
1. Roberts, Sam. “New Demographic Racial Gap Emerges,” The New York Times, May 17, 2007.
-
I think that increasing membership in AIGA is a great idea...but I think many people are not members because of the price. I am a young designer about 4 years removed from school and find it hard to justify the membership dues that AIGA requires.
The AIGA is an excellent organization and I would be a member, but it is not within my budget to do so. So, maybe a slight reduction in cost would boost more membership for this great organization. -
I have to agree that the cost of membership is too inflated, especially when you have to pay additional fees to attend most events. If I recieved a montly publication, or some addtional resources - then I may find the membership fee more reasonable. As an entry level designer, I can barely justify the costs — I would guess that many designers share my opinion.
The group discount is equally expensive. I would bet that more firms would provide their design teams with memberships if they were given better incentive to do so.
Lower the price :: Double the members. -
totally agree with the above. I've considered joining aiga many times, including recently, since i am starting my own business. But the cost keeps stopping me. Members should either receive more benefits or the price needs to drop by 1/3. Additionally, I would like to see more events being thrown by my chapter in Miami!
-
I agree. AIGA is great and offers a place of strength for all designers, but the cost is high in relation to the benefits. That being said, the benefits are nice.
-
There are three desigers in my organization, all of whom are prevented from joining AIGA simply because of the cost.
-
I agree - There are tons of designers in the field, and only a fraction are members of the AIGA - the only factor inhibiting membership is cost. Especially because there are additial fees for many events.
The ratio of benefits to cost is incredibly inbalanced. I think a combination of lower fees and increased benefits would more than double membership in less than a year. -
I think that the members should speak thier mind. Our biggest issue is the price when attempting to recruit new members at my school. I am not saying decrease the price, but increase the member benefits. The mindset still stands- WIIFM what's in it for me? People around the globe are tuned into this radio station, and AIGA needs to tune in as well.
Designers or not, we all like benefits. That is the bottom line. Personally, I think the website is fine. I do not need a paper newsletter, but I would love to not have to purchase an entry to a contest or competition as a member. Event costs are out of my price range as well. These events are excellent opportunities, if you can afford it, that is. -
The benefits are just not worth the cost. Till that is changed, it'll be tough to make a huge increase in memberships.
-
I thought I would have a tough time getting the money together since I am a new designer too. I talked to someone at AIGA when they asked why I didn't renew and they renewed my membership at a "young professional's fee" which helped immensely. I was also able to join while I was in school for a very small fee, too. For me AIGA has been one of those things I hope will allow me to be more involved with our local chapter.
I do get frustrated seeing all of the awesome events that I cannot afford to go to though. If there was a way to connect us online to the events (podcast, video feeds?) that would be great. That would be a great way for me to involve myself with concepts and understanding introduced at events. I would also like to see a more intentional focus on the part of the local chapters as well.
I like that AIGA is challenging itself with this task. I believe the members gained will help to push this challenge further. -
We are very aware of the price of membership and have always considered carefully the setting of fees. One of the issues that prospective members need to consider is the true value of a professional association. It represents an opportunity to invest in the profession you have chosen, which will include the chance to: assist in strengthening the profession; increase respect for the profession; further understanding of the profession; and set professional standards. It is not simply about the tangible items one gets in return. Many of the benefits are long term and intended to improve the viability of all designers’ future in the profession.
We try to keep members informed monthly through Communiqué and on the web. In order to respect members’ interest in demonstrating our commitment to sustainable practices, we moderate the amount of print materials developed.
The benefits of membership involve an investment on behalf of each member that is three times their dues, since AIGA raises money from program fees and sponsorship that complements the fee revenue.
AIGA’s dues are comparable to other professional associations (SEGD: $290; IDSA: $315; etc.), and many members of both organizations feel that AIGA’s services surpass those of the other organizations. AIGA’s professional level dues have increased over the past 10 years, but only at the rate of inflation.
We remain sensitive to the financial concerns of prospective members and yet we are also working hard to achieve the ambitions of a profession that is impatient for the recognition it deserves. In the opinion of the board, which has given great consideration to this issue, we cannot achieve all that we want by reducing the value of the relationship and by providing more tangible items to members, but rather we must keep investing in activities and communication that inform businesses, media and the public about the value of professional design. -
I've been a member of AIGA since the early 90s. Granted, our studio pays the membership dues for the entire staff. But as a partner in the firm, I see this as an investment in our profession.
As Ric writes in his follow-up comments, what other professional design organization (other than perhaps AIA) is as visible and active as AIGA? And I can think on none who are actively working to raise the level of awareness and respect for communication design in the business community.
It's interesting that when talking with peers we lament that other professional service providers, such as doctors, lawyers and even architects, garner more respect for what they do. Isn't it slightly ironic that we then won't support the professional organization that is trying to help us do just that.
I tell my students that the $75 they'll spend on membership is one of the best investments they make towards their future. Not only are they provided with amazing professional benefits at a cut-rate price, a student membership listed on their resume gets them in the door to our studio for a portfolio review every time!
Are dues really that expensive? With 260 working days in a year, it's just slightly more than $1 for each working day. Maybe we should look at it as the cost of doing business; treat it like overhead costs like the ones we do have to deal with (e.g. electricity, computers, software, etc.). Or perhaps a better way of looking at it: $295 is equal to roughly 85 Starbuck's lattes. With that comparison it seems like a pretty good deal to me. (Or maybe I just drink too much coffee!)
And, while I'm reluctant to single out any benefit over others: the 15% Adobe software discount given to AIGA members really means that if you're buying software at full price, the amount you save as a member could be almost equal to the membership dues. Think about that when you buy your CS3 upgrade.
For a full list of membership benefits check out:
http://www.aiga.org/content.cfm/benefits
And for a description of how AIGA spends member dues check out:
http://www.aiga.org/content.cfm/membership-investment -
Ok, the intangibles Ric mentioned? Here is my take...
I have been a member of AIGA for about 6 or 7 years and I have been actively involved for about 4-5 of those years. I have had my membership purchased for me only once (and that was most recently). I have paid for every conference on my own since 2001. I have always seen the value in putting back into my proffession, and since i have been a board member of a local chapter, my commitment has grown even stronger.
Really, spending is about priorities and I have made this a priority in my life. I know that my money is being spent on things like growing our profession, making more people aware of who we are, what we do and how important the profession is. I know that we now have a seat on the United Nations and we provide scholarships and mentorships to those who need it most. We are also leading the way for sustainable design in our profession among other very important initiatives you can read about on this site...I am just scratching the surface of what this organization is doing.
I know that I can call just about any AIGA member in the United States and they will help me in good times and in bad. I have met and been inspired by some of the greatest leaders in our profession, some of which I can now call my friend.
I am not quite sure what all these tangible benefits are that people are expecting to get? What ever happened to just the idea of giving back? This is a non-profit organization working for me and you...in all honesty, that's all I need to know. That in and of itself is worth a lot, despite all the other fore-mentioned intangibles.
Those that think events should be free have obviously never thrown or put on an event to know what goes into it. If you have and know how we can get better sponsors to keep event costs down, I would encourage you to join your local board...give back that knowledge.
In 10, 20, 30 years, where will we be, what will being a designer mean...will I even have a job? Well, you better bet AIGA will be at the forefront of answering and defining these questions and they will be there to support you whether you have a job or not. You can make it a priority to make sure your voice is heard a long the way, or you can wait until you get whatever it is you are expecting to receive...either way AIGA is there working for you.
Ok, I may sound a bit preachy, but that is because I am passionate about this organization.
Remember, nothing worth while comes cheap or free...the value is there...sometimes you have to just look beyond the obvious to see it. -
member #0003149, since 1986. couldn't WAIT to pay the higher non-student, non-entry level fees back then, and did so, coughing up more dough, for more "benefits." never had any company pay, other than myself. could talk about the intangible benefits for weeks on end, and my "career" has been helped in no small part due to my involvement with aiga, though it should be acknowledged that one gets what one gives. "Ask not what ..." etc etc. WIIFM? a narrow question with a breadth of answers.
fyi, aiga has made it easier, allowing payments to be made quarterly (or maybe in thirds?), softening the financial bite. no it is not posted, yes there are no doubt kinks in this system internally, and yes, you have to pay to play.
and on another note, decisions like this (membership numbers, fees) aren't made in a vacuum. they are made by an active and engaged board from many parts of the design spectrum, covering not only big guns, but small squirts and academia. by the time an initiative has been rolled out, it has been beaten and fussed into shape for a period of any number of months or even years.
ric's (and the board's) stance is no doubt to position aiga for the future as well as today. but we can't invest in the future, we can only invest today. it's not always easy to talk the talk AND walk the walk. -
I am a veteran designer who's been in the industry for over 20 years. I've attended some AIGA events, but have only taken the extra step to become a member once.
I fully agree with many of the people who have posted here. The price is too high in light of the few benefits you receive. For example, my local chapter has essentially taken the summer off. So members get a 9 month membership for the price of 12.
I do think AIGA has significant benefits for some people. I've seen several of my friends benefit a great deal from their memberships, but that was more a factor of the amount of effort they put into it rather than getting what they paid for. If you're committed to networking and working as a volunteer then you can benefit from the membership.
Honestly, I don't necessarily "buy" the arguments that AIGA is "at the forefront" of the issues that will impact us as professionals today and in the future. That's not to say it isn't happening, I just haven't seen it. I've seen MUCH more legal and professional effort from groups like the Graphic Artists Guild than from AIGA.
Having said that, if you're one of the ones AIGA "works" for, then GREAT! However, I think you can't discount the many people who feel the price is too high. Personally, I think the price should come down a little and the benefits should go up some too. I suspect that the bump in memberships you'd see would offset the slight loss in revenue per member.
Just my 2 cents. -
I've been a member for a few years now at a student rate. There were a lot of great activities in Denver, but I'm in Austin now which is a little less active. My affiliation with AIGA hasn't helped as much as I had hoped in finding a job. It seems mostly to be an association where small to large firms with a bank roll can promote themselves. The networking is great but doesn't seem to work for an independent mid-level designers such as myself. I don't even have enough to renew this year at the discount price. And really, I have to ask, should I renew?
-
I definitely have had a love-grumpy relationship with AIGA over the past 10 years of being a member. But interesting enough - it's never been about the cost. Many fine points have been made about the value of being a member - both tangible and intangible - so I'll skip the redundancy.
So seriously folks - if one of the only solutions is to ask AIGA to drop prices? Then you're just not that creative. Do an extra freelance job - write a proposal to your boss on how it increases your professional development - tell your family to contribute for your birthday instead of a BestBuy gift card. Maybe even save up for it each month? Heaps of ways to figure it out. Designer bake sale?
Or the other solution is to ask AIGA to increase it's benefits? What - do we all need new ponies? They've got our (meaning the design industry) backs. They work on big things that effect the industry - and continue to increase the value of design past just getting a cheaper subscription to a magazine.
You might ask yourself what you want out of it? Most of it is already there. Community, a place to chat among peers, networking and events, making lifelong friends, access to ICOGRADA, reduced prices on stuff and AIGA conferences that also cost heaps but also worth just about every penny...
Yup - the old saying is true - you get out of it what you put into it. And many times things you never expect. Not only do I continue to get everything above - but a respectable designer I met decided she could put up with me and I got to become her husband about 2 years ago. (hi sweetie) And I reckon that’s just about the best of both the tangible and intangible.
Anyway – I agree I would rather spend more money on coffee – but I’m pretty sure your membership costs are not going to change. So you’ll either just have to figure out a way to cover the costs - get some sort of spy recording device to put on someone who is a member so you can get some of the benefits - or stop complaining. Remember, we're creative - we can do anything - so this should be easy.
Feel free to say howdy if you’re going to be in Denver for the Conference.
stuart@idahostew.com
303-321-7101 -
I teach design and multimedia to high school juniors and seniors who can earn college credit if they get an A or B. It would be cool for them to be able to join at the student rate.
-
For me personally, the $210 associate designer fee for ex-students right out of school seems the most hefty. If my school is any indication, far less than half of graduates actually get jobs in the design industry within a year out of school. If a person was able to afford membership at the student rate during school, which many can, the almost tripling of the membership fee post-graduation is tough to justify. It was for me, at least. Plus, the young designers who are lucky (or talented) enough to get jobs are often working very hard in their first few years -- I was working more than 50 hours per week, leaving little time for AIGA events. For me, it was hard to justify membership when I didn't rationalize I had the time or energy to be involved in the first place. Although it sounds like Rick and the AIGA board have given serious thought to the fees, it seems like a reduction in the young designers fee might bring more of us recent graduates into the association for the long term.
With that said, this is my first week as a member, which contradicts everything I just rambled about! -
I agree with Ryan's post. I'm a few months out of school and although I did land a job, I still can't afford to pay even the discounted associate rate. Every bit of cash counts when you're living paycheck to paycheck, because you never know when the car you've had since high school is going to fall apart. Even if I could afford it, The benefits for me at this time would be minimal since like Ryan I'm working overtime to work my way up and I don't have time for participation. My student membership expires this fall, and I'll miss being a part of AIGA for the time being.
-
Just a quick comment to add to the string:
Even if the annual AIGA membership feels a bit high, I continue to appreciate the fact that every AIGA chapter makes their events open to the public and available on a pay "per view" basis as well. I held off on professional / faculty membership until this year, but continued to pay the door charge to get into all of the events I could attend via the Nebraska AIGA chapter.
I'm pleased to reaffirm the thoughts about investing in something rather than assuming we're buying a dollar-to-dollar match worth of cool schwag from the AIGA. The Nebraska chapter continues to invest greatly in the design life of the state and to provide a place for all of us to routinely connect with one another. Adding my funds to that investment via event charges or via the membership charge just makes a lot of sense.
Even if the membership is out of your price range right now, keep attending the events and supporting this organization that way in the meantime. Hopefully we'll hit the 1/10th population of working American designers that Ric's asking for eventually... -
I sympathize with those who feel an AIGA membership is too expensive. Not all that long ago I was a broke student and currently, I live in an expensive city. Still, I think the membership is an invaluable tool, particularly for young designers.
For several years I was an uninvolved, relatively disinterested AIGA member. As a result of looking for my next career move, I became more active in the organization. I slowly realized how much you, the individual designer, can directly benefit from being a member. My current employer found me on the AIGA website. At least twenty others have contacted me because they saw my work there. Business people up on design, doing the hiring, know where to look for good designers and the AIGA site is one of the first places they go. If you want to be more then a production person you need to know business, have a network and be constantly engaged in the design community - AIGA offers this. The organization isn’t perfect, no large group is, but it does give you a lot for your membership, not all of which is a tangible figure on paper.
On a personal level, I just like hanging out with other creative people. AIGA events provide a chance to talk with other designers, share stories with people who know what kerning is and maybe meet some designers you look up to.
I think you should ask yourself what it costs not to be a member? Personally, I think it's a lot. -
Just to have an organization providing a unified voice for our industry is worth $295. Having a central institution that brings about local level initiatives where every month there are conferences, events, exhibitions and publications further justify the $295 annual membership fee. Additionally, there are many AIGA resources that help improve our professional practice, such as Communique, Design Business and Ethics, the National website, etc… The extraordinary job that Ric and the National team has done in articulating design value has helped me and thousands of design professionals make a case for design to prospective clients, substantiate fees, and gain a more influential position within the client’s organization. This alone, is worth $295.
This blog should turn the discussion away from $295 and focus on how each of us can help to make our organization financially sustainable and more influential among the country’s business and cultural communities. Students and professionals in all relevant fields should engage in a common effort to empower our professional organization. A unified voice is more effective than chatter. -
why not just give a discount for the first year and bump up the price the following years?
-
Michael, you are absolutely right. This is what we do offer to all students the year they graduate is a half price associate membership for the first year.
-
I've been an AIGA member for 10 years. Recently my membership lapsed and I decided to take a year off as a means of re-evaluating the value of my membership from a fresh perspective.
I did a lot of thinking in those 12 months — about what it means to belong, the obligations we have to ourselves, our peers, predecessors and successors. I probably came up with more questions than answers, but here are some of my thoughts so far. They're in no particular order, but I'll address the dollars first, since the bulk of the this thread has centered on affordability:
1. Sometimes it is about the money.
I gave a young designer a ride home a few months ago. She'd just shelled out $2,500 and taken a month off work to volunteer to participate in an outreach project. On the way home she pointed out the best dumpster for finding food. I get that she doesn't have $75 for an AIGA membership. I respect it. If you're someone that can't afford the cost of membership I think that's alright. Join when you can afford it and when it makes sense for you.
2. Membership is not a transaction.
You can pay your dues every year and then sit back and wait for something to happen, but it just doesn't work like that. AIGA is not a transactional experience. What you get out of your membership has very little to do with what you pay. If you put a lot in you can get a lot out. To some that will seem like perfect logic. To others it may seem less generous than it could be.
3. AIGA is a conduit to a creative community.
It's not the only conduit, and it's not the only community, but it is the largest and most organized and that matters.
4. There are many ways to support your profession.
Paying dues to AIGA is one of them. Being active in AIGA is definitely another. Doing good work, teaching, mentoring, charging a fair price, turning down spec, hiring interns, sharing your knowledge, taking on nonprofit clients, giving to scholarships, using your skills to help the rural poor, opening your studio to high school kids and teaching design summer camp to 5th graders are some others. Do as much as you're able.
5. 90% of a person's AIGA experience is local.
That is, we think of AIGA in terms of the experiences, opportunities and resources our local chapter provides. It sometimes bothers me that only 25% of my dues are invested locally, but:
6. It's a little like giving money to GreenPeace.
I don't have the time or the inclination to ram oil tankers in a Zodiac, but I want to support the people who do. An awful lot goes on on the national level on members' behalf, most of which would be impossible for an individual to achieve on their own and much of which is difficult to bullet point in a list of member benefits. For example, what does it mean that AIGA is applying for NGO status with the UN? How does reforming ballot design benefit my practice? What's so important about preserving the legacy of designers in a museum collection? It's hard to define these initiatives as "member benefits." They are collective benefits, and one has to be to be the kind of person that's okay with that.
7. People do get upset when you don't belong.
There were people that were offended that I didn't renew my membership. That surprised me, but I also "get it." Groucho Marx quipped that he'd never want to belong to any club that would have someone like him for a member. I think the converse of that is true as well. Still, a mature organization has to allow for the possibility that not everyone wants to belong. An organization that accepts all comers also has to embrace (not just accept) dissent. On balance I believe AIGA does a pretty good job of this, but we tend to remember the exceptions.
8. AIGA = PBS
When I was an AIGA chapter president (San Francisco, 2004-2006) our chapter grew significantly (from 4th to 2nd-largest). It continues to grow. I think its important to note that we always held the philosophy that just because you're a designer doesn't obligate you to join AIGA, and we never placed the burden of that expectation on our prospective members. Instead, we operated more like public broadcasting.
Only about 1 in 9 people who watch PBS are actually members. The rest reap the benefits for free. The ratios are comparable for AIGA. Whether you join or not, the organization is still going to advocate for your profession. It's still going to produce content and frame many of the discussions that help define our daily practice. If you value that advocacy, if you consume that content, if you want to add your voice to those discussions (and if you can afford it) those are reasons to join.
No one really joins for the free tote bag.
So, for me, for who I am, for what I want from my career and my practice, AIGA represents a good value.
I renewed my membership (one year, to the day, after it expired).
I'm investing in AIGA in the belief that it will invest in me. -
That's the informative, fair and honest comment I was looking for. Thanks cchs.
-
Memberships to professional organizations are what you make of it. If you don't use your membership by getting involved then it's really not worth it no matter how much it costs. I look at my AIGA membership as an investment in my career and future.
-
"Quid pro quo" and membership in any advocacy organization simply can't occupy the same thought space--at least in terms of "tangibles."
And AIGA, like most membership organizations of any repute, delivers far more than it asks in dues--regardless of where one is on their career arc or how involved they might choose to be. The case for perceived return increasing with active involvement has been better said above, but for those who can't be as involved as they might like for time-management or financial reasons, if nothing else, your dues are worth this:
1. No one individual or small group can work to effectively de-marginalize this profession, i.e., when you walk out with the gig at a price that represents the value you deliver, you'll be glad that hands other than yours are working to make value pricing a reality.
2. No one individual or small group can document and archive the history and practioneers of this profession, i.e. when Prospect Knows From Whom They Want to Crib says "We want an X-esque type thing here" and you sagely nod while thinking "Riiight... what did so-and-so's stuff look like?" you'll know where to run for the cliff notes.
3. No one individual or small group can offer direct access to as wide a community of communication design professionals. Got a question for your rock-star designer hero? Look them up and ask--likelier than not, you'll get an answer, i.e. when you're chatting up your peers at the next chapter happy hour, you can name drop about your correspondence with Design God X--concealing your glee with the appropriate nonchalance, of course.
4. See the much more lucid discussion of intangibles above, i.e., it's an investment, etc, etc.
Personally, it'd take a while for me to wrap my head around what I've "gotten" out of membership: relationships, extraordinary experiences (thanks for China, AIGA!), growth/education of course... all nice/valuable/"worth" it...
...But you can also get struck by an AIGA bolt from the blue bottom-line wise:
We've had the good fortune to be found in the AIGA Directory by prospects that converted to clients. Why were these clients looking for designers in the AIGA Directory? I asked, they answered: "we wanted to find area designers that weren't fly-by-night," i.e., professionals--and the AIGA Directory was a first-line filter in their process. So, I get money because I joined, filled out a profile and could do what I said could? Wish I could replicate that "phone rings with prospect on line confident I'm pre-qualified for their needs" performance across other marketing channels...
...And if you're a design manager, corporate membership has got to be the single most cost-effective "benefit" you could possibly offer hires. I have a very small team, but if I had 40 (oy...) in my charge, I'd pick up the tab for all of them:
1. For those new to professional practice it imparts that "I'm a real, live part-of-something" designer glow;
2. For the experienced, it imparts that "Thank goodness, I don't have to pay myself!" designer glow. Disclaimer: Still Cheap It's A Value Pay Yourself If That's Your Hand/Stop Drinking All Those Lattes If You're Solo/Starting/Employer Won't See The Light;
3) For all parts of the arc, it offers remarkably inexpensive education/training opportunities depending on a given local chapter's event offerings.
So, for those who can but haven't on the managerial side: be a big ball of warm fuzzy concern (a sincere one...) for those in your cares' professional development... and look like a hero on the Krazy Cheap.
Anywhoo, I hope AIGA does double up and that we each endeavor to the extent we can to make that happen. Scale matters, the profession matters, AIGA matters, so have a cup of Kool Aid if you're on the sidelines and get in the game.
/preachy rambling screed -
I've been a member for years and do believe in goals of this organization. However, I don't feel as if the events and the print materials I have received in the mail are as helpful as they could be. I don't believe that any of the events can be free to all members, understandably, but I need more reason to shell out that much money that I could use to further my business and skills or just put food on the table and a roof over my head.
To attain the respect of say a doctor or lawyer or architect, I believe that this organization would then need to set a standard of excellence beyond paying a fee and checking a box in our profile. Lawyers must pass a bar exam, Doctors spend countless years and hours in rigorous education and Architects must be licensed or registered like engineers, surveyors and contractors.
To gain respect, we must earn it. Make us need something more to earn the respect this organization wants to achieve such as fulfilling one, some or all of a list of criteria, such as letters of recommendation of clients or professors, graduating with a certain degree from accredited colleges at an acceptable GPA, etc. How many desktop publishers who know basic program skills claim to be a graphic designer? If you are doubling the size of your membership says nothing of the quality of designers your members might be.
If its the corporations that need to be more informed of the value of our profession, what is it we are doing to educate them? Graphic designers already know how valuable we are, so we don't need to to keep hearing it. For what the organization goals are, then I would rather see more collateral going straight to the corporate world or in ads or commercials that will show us as more valuable to those that need to understand most. Designers talking to designers really feels more like we are just tooting our own horn. If we want to truly make a difference, it needs to be designers talking to the world. If you really want to make a different, educate the executives on branding and the value of design.
Give us more education, give us a greater skill base, make these events truly help us as designers.
I do non-profit pro-bono work and volunteering and really can't justify spending more time networking/volunteering through AIGA, though I would like to, when I would rather be helping children or disease through my other organizations. I do believe when you put that amount of time into the organization, you get more out of the membership, but that is not your average member target, especially if you plan on doubling. Try to get more involvement without requiring attendance - I think that is the greatest obstacle in our busy lives. Make meetings and events available via webcasting and get more input in what we would like to see at all these events by more surveys. If you are trying to be a unified voice, then allow more voices to be heard through the technology available today. These discussions are a great step in that direction.
So my conclusion are:
1. If you want to see continued growth in membership, it needs to grow as an organization in making the memberships more valuable for ALL members by ensuring the events and chapters are more essential and accessible.
2. If we want to make the profession more respected like doctors, lawyers, architects, etc..., we need to see more requirements for the field through licensing/registration or a higher level of education (I just don't see this happening in such a subjective field) or by more directly educating the corporate world.
3. If you want designers that carry the aiga behind the name to be as respected as the doctors, architects, etc, then the membership needs to be more exclusive based on the quality, not quantity, of the members.
Thanks for giving me a place to be heard. -
more exclusive? probably.
cheaper? maybe.
better benefits? definitely!
when i tell clients that i'm an aiga member it means nothing to them.
when the architects in my building say they're aia members it means they're really architects.
what does being a member of the aiga mean? it means that i paid to be a member. it doesn't mean i'm a good designer. it doesn't mean i went to school. it doesn't mean i have any formal training. it doesn't mean you should do business with me.
don't get me wrong. i enjoy being and member and i think there needs to be a professional organization, but it needs to be professional, for professionals.
over and out. -
In order to increase membership, perhaps there should be more chapters. I live in San Jose where there is plenty of design going on. Why isn't there a chapter here where I live? Going to S.F. is far away after working all day.
-
Hello,
Like Rebecca, I also work and live in San Jose. My wife and I try to attend as many AIGA SF chapter events as we can. Between San Jose and Palo Alto there are plenty of small and large active design communities. I think that Adobe and Apple would help support activities for a AIGA San Jose/Silicon Valley chapter.
Regards,
Sal Randazzo -
I agree with Rosalina.
Especially when it comes to webcasting events - this would benefit everyone, especially people who may not have local chapters in their area. When it comes to benefits, often it fully depends on your local chapter - this is where a lot of people may lose out on benefits.
Also I agree that being a member of AIGA should mean more than it currently does. You paid for the membership, so what? it doesn't mean you're a designer. Maybe there should be an added professional level to the AIGA - one with higher critera for acceptance. -
On one hand, it's a good idea to double membership to increase revenue for more benefits, etc.... And also to increase public awareness about communication and design.
On the other hand, it might mean people join for the wrong reasons. Maybe people join just to promote their own business, maybe that business is badly designed and promotes the wrong messages. I'm being a little pessimistic, but things like this probably will happen if we put this "20,000 quota" into effect.
Why not have separate memberships, like for business people, designers, students, etc... Sort of like the way fees work now, but make new categories for people who aren't designers but are interested in sharing design. -
I've been a AIGA member, but currrently I am not. AIGA feels more like a club than a professional organization. We have our meetings, we have our publications, newsletters and card, but no one in the real world knows what AIGA is. Does it matter whether you are a member or not?? Not to my clients or my colleagues.
AIGA needs to create value. I will gladly pay my membership dues when membership matters and the general public know what it is when I say that I'm an AIGA member. Otherwise, I'd rather save my money for a Starbucks every morning. -
I agree that the price is on the high side. I do pay for my own membership straight out of college. I saw it as an invest to be able to put my portfolio online. I live in the burbs of Atlanta, so it is a little hard to get to the meetings. There is also less motivation due to my distance and that I don't know to many other designers in AIGA. I have to renew at the end of October and this will probably be my last, unless I move to a more active city or area.
-
I have a friend who is an Executive Chef. Through our friendship I have learned all about how the ACF (American Culinary Federation) provide accredited certification programs for all levels of Culinary Professionals, from Certified Culinarian to Certified Master Chef.
Just because you aren't a member and aren't certified doesn't mean you can't cook, or aren't brilliant, or even that you can't become a world-famous restauranteur, TV-Host and Cook Book Author. But you cannot claim to be a Certified Master Chef without passing the eight-day peer-judged gastronomic gauntlet.
I would really love it if the AIGA offered some sort of professional accreditation along the lines of the ACF. -
"AIGA’s dues are comparable to other professional associations (SEGD: $290; IDSA: $315; etc.)"
Arguably, the most comparable professional organization, the Art Directors Club, is currently $100 (almost 33%) less per year.
I've been back and forth on renewing since my membership expired about two years ago. I can't afford to go to conferences, even with the 30% of my dues that go toward them. Membership is primarily a networking opportunity for me, and with that in mind, the $300 fee is just too much for me to swallow. -
People have been all over the board about this, debating various issues, but not many have addressed why the heck AIGA needs so much money from each person in the first place, what they do with it, and who that gives access to. The question for me isn't how I can scrimp and save to buy my way in with the 'in' kids (new designer, broken down car, living paycheck to paycheck not getting paid what I'm worth, etc.), or even what the tangible results are, although that's big, too. The question for me is: where the heck does all that money go?
Is there really that much overhead? I doubt it. Obviously, I'm not a member, but it seems members are saying that even events and such are out of the leagues of many, based on price.
Richard, you make the case that AIGA dues are comparable to other organizations. Great. Highway robbery is comparable to armed robbery, but that doesn't tell me anything, and saying it's comparable doesn't convince me why I should hand over money to YOU. Also, you say it's not about tangible results, but try making a case to most bosses for membership based on "strengthening the profession". It's a lofty goal, but the fact is, my boss doesn't give a crap about that, and he's not going to shell out the money until he can concretely see what I/he/the business will get out of it.
Also, one other thing not mentioned here by others: diversity. I'm one of your 10% people-of-color designers. When you look at the fact that statistically, females and people of color (I am both) still generally make less money than white men, being inflexible about your membership price means that you are NOT welcoming of diversity, of the people who are already under-represented in this field.
You say you want more people and more diversity. But I don't see you putting your money where your mouth is. Why not offer scholarships, or a sliding scale payment system? Why should I pay the same (making $13,000 a year) as some white dude in New York making $150,000?
I would love to support the profession. But before that, the profession has to support me. Making your organization more accessible to individuals like me will give voice to a much wider range of people than the traditional demographic, and might help a. attract up-and-coming talent from said different backgrounds, b. represent concerns for minority issues, and c. enrich the American design community with broader cultural aesthetics than those derived from a white, middle-upper class background and higher education system.
I believe in the ideals. I would love to belong. So would, I'm sure, many young, poor designers who may or may not be people of color. If you want to double your membership, you're going to have to look to us, the new ones coming up, because the older ones already know about you, and have made up their minds one way or another. If you want to be a leader in this industry now, and in the future, then take a stand. Revise the way you do things. Give my boss some reasons he can understand. And be truly welcoming of diversity--economic, as well as ethnic.
Put your money where your mouth is. No excuses. -
Haha, oh man. I love the hype and would be all about strengthening the community, but.....yeah.....315 bucks a year is still 315 bucks a year. I really can't comment about any other reason then the financial reason for not joining. I check AIGA pretty regularly and do appreciate the resources they website gives me, but again... why spend 315 bucks when I can subscribe to Print and Communication Arts for under 100 bucks a year?
The majority of the "Exclusive" benefits you offer I would rarely, if ever, use. I do appreciate all the print benefits you would throw at me, but again....I can't justify 315 dollars. Neither can my boss. Drop it down to 150-200 and we'll talk. Have your people call my people. -
In many ways I think the AIGA represents many of the challenges that continues to haunt our industry, as a whole, as we stand on the doorstep of the early hours of the digital revolution.
The AIGA is employing a 20th century model in a 21st century economy. Most members shell out $300+ dollars and are simply never able to get their money's worth, regardless of how much they agree with the organization and its stated goals.
In truth, there is really no reason for this. The AIGA needs to evolve into a fully collaborative organization that makes generous use of the many social applications and capabilities that -- ironically -- most of us designers use every day in other contexts.
Why is this site, for example, not way more social? We should have location-based tools that run through the site that allow us to congregate spontaneously via our mobile devices.
Every member should have a blog, much like the Barack Obama site has been doing for at least a year with its my.barackobama.com. How hard would it be to setup a my.aiga.org? Apps like KickApps allow sites to have this functionality up and running in mere hours and for relatively low cost.
Each member should be able to create, on the fly, their own user profiles and interactive portfolios. Perhaps even upload interactive presentations (one could embed SlideShares into their profile areas, with very little effort).
Why not, again through readily available social apps, allow users to form small ad hoc committees that could move much more quickly -- and in Wiki style -- than the old school 20th century committes? That's not to say you do away with the old school committees, they still have their place, but certainly ad hoc groups like this could make far better use of the global landscape of the AIGA's user base.
Ironically, most of us employ these techniques in many of our OTHER every day scenarios, whether it's social networks or collaborative work environments. Why not here?
If the AIGA wants to double its numbers, it had better take a page from the playbooks of the Obama campaign, the open source movement, Wikipedia and others. It, just like our industry, has already wasted precious time in joining the rest of the business world in the 21st century.
Jump in, the water's great!!!
.chris{} -
Ric, What does an AIA membership or SAG dues cost? What do their membership numbers look like? Would existing members pay more if there were more tangible benefits such as a client referral service, or federal and state lobbying on publicly funded projects? Is there not a professional prestige associated with a smaller, more focused group?
-
Jai, thanks for the issues you’ve raised, and we welcome the chance to respond.
You ask where the money goes. AIGA’s overhead is not considerable and we pride ourselves on lean, effective management (we have 20 staff supporting more than 22,000 members). On our site, there is an explanation of where we invest our resources, highlighting an additional important fact—that we raise $2 for every $1 in membership fees, so that the value of each member’s contribution is actually tripled. http://www.aiga.org/membership-investment
If we were to double membership, the increased resources would be used to support members with more professional development opportunities, seek a stronger voice on public policy for the profession and increase efforts to communicate the value of design to business.
You also ask what AIGA is doing to promote diversity in the design field, which is a matter of great importance not only to the relevance of this organization, but to the profession overall. AIGA encourages mentorship programs, such as the ones developed by Project Osmosis (the kit they developed is in the process of being updated but will be available on our site soon), to reach young people who are currently underserved by design education. This year alone, Worldstudio AIGA Scholarships gave $65,000 to help minority and economically disadvantaged students of design and the visual arts. http://www.aiga.org/worldstudio-scholarship
And an online archive and physical exhibition is underway to honor the insights and achievements of diverse designers so that they may serve as role models for the next generation. http://www.aiga.org/diversity-archive
Through these initiatives and more, AIGA promotes diversity in all of our chapters.
Membership fees will not be based on either ethnicity or gender, just as we will not have different fees based on the size of the market in which a designer practices. We do recognize that younger designers earn less and should have a chance to move up to full membership, so we offer progressive rates for students, first year graduates and associate members (now extended for two more years).
If you have additional questions, I would encourage you to contact our staff directly. While we cannot necessarily be the least expensive association, we will always aim to be the highest-value investment for our members. -
Daily coffee: $1.50
AIGA Professional Membership: $315
Apple 15" Laptop, with everything: $4,000
Benefits gained through active AIGA membership: Priceless
and: The ability to mimic a great commercial: Awesome! -
I love you Jen. Brilliant!
-
Doug, since I know you are in Dallas, the AIA membership fee for Dallas is $781 per year. For Graphic Artists Guild, it is $200 per year. AIA has 56,000 architect members; GAG probably has about 1500 members, from my last conversation with them.
It is difficult to say whether members would pay more for additional tangible benefits, particularly since our diverse membership varies in their individual preferences for services and benefits. We have tried to avoid a referral service, except through the directory, since we want to avoid recommending one member designer over another. When we receive calls, we encourage use of the directory to find qualified designers. And we are already active on state and local legislative fronts, although not as active as we would like to be and could be if we were larger.
Is there professional prestige associated with a smaller, more focused group? Yes, there can be, but there would also be less credibility in articulating the case for designers in front of business and government audiences and would naturally have a tendency to be inward looking (being exclusive) rather than outward looking, which we try to accomplish by being inclusive. AIGA has consciously decided that it should focus on enhancing the relevance of the design profession, not celebrating a small group of designers, which argues for a much broader representation. -
This conversation is exactly what motivated our recent annual board retreat.
How do we make AIGA relevant and compelling to the creative community in our area?
We're right on the leading edge of our next board cycle, and a lot of the ideas we discussed at retreat are just that at this moment - ideas.
However, I can say that part of our strategy is to offer a full year of valuable and engaging programming opportunities, and we're going to do our dead-level best to make mostly FREE for all members. Our goal is to secure funding and/or sponsorship for every event we put on so that the only folks putting up dough would be those who are not currently members - but even then, we're going to try and keep the fees low. The goal is inclusion, not exclusion.
Additionally, we're looking to develop our web presence as a forum for the creative community as a whole. Soliciting active content contributions from designers, filmmakers, writers, street artists, motion graphics artists, printers, etc.
One of our new board members sent this quote around recently.
" Inspiration should never come from your own medium." - Stefan Sagmeister
We hope that by opening the doors to everyone, and by radically changing our perspective to be outward facing into our community that we'll make AIGA a "no brainer" for folks looking to tap into the real creative essence of New Orleans.


Comments